VOD Distribution in India + New Blockchain Distribution Platform/Service

by Orly Ravid

After participating in the Film Bazaar market in India (connected to the International Film Festival of India, now in Goa), I decided to investigate the distribution potential in India, specifically VOD and Blockchain and the distribution potential for independent cinema.

A 2018 report in Business Today noted that the OTT market in India is worth ½ billion and will grow to be 5 billion by 2023 with Fox’s Hotstar leading with 75 million subscribers with American companies such as Netflix and Amazon in hot pursuit. The reason for the growth is rising affluence and adoption across demographics including in rural areas. Today, the VOD market is AVOD-dominated but Business Today anticipates a flip with AVOD going down and SVOD and TVOD doubling from their present estimated 18% of the market.

This is fun—search “Film distribution in India” on Google and you get a nice scroll of logos with links to a bunch of companies. And you can find a list on Wikipedia.

At Film Bazaar I interviewed a couple of top players in the VOD distribution space, and also MinersINC, a new Blockchain distribution platform/service.

First, I spoke to Ajay Chacko is Co-founder & CEO of Arré, one of the country’s foremost original digital content brands. Arré was founded in 2015 by B. Saikumar, Ajay Chacko & Sanjay Ray Chaudhuri. Arré offers multimedia content across genres & formats and has won many international & domestic awards & accolades for its work in digital fiction & non-fiction. Arré Studio is also working on large-format original shows in collaboration with domestic and international OTT platforms as well as broadcast television networks. Ajay has over 2 decades of experience in media & financial services. He spent over a decade with Network18 and was Group COO and also President A+E – TV18 JV in his last held roles with the Group. He has also worked with IL&FS, Sharekhan and the Indian Express Group prior to his stint with Network18. The company’s website can be found here.

Q [to Ajay Chacko of Arré]: What are key trends today in India with respect to audiences/consumers getting content (please comment on both type of content and means of consumption/viewing (technology and price model))?:

A: The Indian digital media market has seen renewed traction ever since data prices crashed with the advent of JIO & the subsequent competitive intensity in the telecom market; the digital media audience is approaching the 400 million mark. More than (>)85% of content consumed is on the mobilewith the structure of consumption now pretty much getting aligned to what it was in the case of TV but with a different idiom i.e. audiences are watching long form shows and movies, albeit on-demand and of the kind they’d like to watch. This has also created a boom in original content commissioned by OTT platformssince TV content in India has isn’t really working when it comes to individual level consumption (remember India is a single TV household where most programming was catering to semi-urban and rural housewives since they formed the primary ratings driven chunk of viewership). The granularity of the Indian market is reflected by its languages and consumption driven by regional and national languages – these trend in the long run to be 50/50 or thereabouts (Hindi: Regional Indian languages like Bengali, Tamil, Telegu, Marathi etc.). The current roughly 800 million TV audiences which is fairly penetrated has reflected this trend and this is also showing up in digital with YouTube India reporting that almost half of its 200 million+ audience is coming from regional markets/ watching regional language content. Video market for English content is at the ‘uppermost socio-economic’ strata but it has never exceeded 4-5% of the overall pie. In fact, English TV entertainment did not cross 2% market share despite it being present in India for over two decades.

India has also been a predominantly ad-funded marketwhen it comes to even fiction/ entertainment. Currently the OTT space is 95%+ AVOD (audience numbers) and some players like Netflix, Amazon, Alt Balaji, Eros Now etc. are trying to push a subscription- based model with some degree of success. Even after 2.5 decades of the existence of cable TV with over 500 channels, India still remains a 70%+ advertising driven market and cable/ pay TV subscription packs are available for 300+ channels at less than 2.5 dollars a month.The consumption trend when it comes to the ‘pay for content’ aspect is still pretty much in the Indian idiom of being ad-driven (various models have emerged here – for example brand integrations into stories has also emerged as an important line of revenue for Independent content players as well as some AVOD platforms).

Q: What about piracy concerns and copyright infringement / protection in India?

A: Piracy has always been an issue in India though I would not put it to be the number one problem as most content in India is freely available since its ad driven/ AVOD. There are many steps being taken by industry associations to help tackle piracy when it comes to music and movies with some degree of success. Digitization has also helped in freeing the movie business from the distribution related leakages.

Q: To what extent is there an appetite / market for American independent cinema in India?

A: Like I mentioned in my earlier point, American Indie cinema has limited appeal, maybe restricted to the top tier of film-buffs etc. in terms of percentage share of the market. However, in terms numbers due to the sheer size of the market there maybe opportunities to have a couple of hundred thousand folks access these thru digital platforms/ OTT services.

Q: I hear documentaries are more popular in India than they used to be in large part due to services such as Netflix—what can you say about that?

A: Much as one would love for this to be true, it isn’t. Docs haven’t really taken off in any meaningful way and one can spend an entire day analyzing why 🙂

A couple of stray examples really don’t break this trend.

Q: Please comment about Amazon, Netflix, and Blockchain with respect to your market (India).

A: The entry of international players like Netflix, Amazon etc. has hastened the process of creation of quality original programming made for digital. This is an important breakthrough in the Indian market and a lot of the OTT platforms (who were banking on catchup tv content) now have realized that they need to up their game and come up with quality original programming in Indian and regional languages. This has thrown up a lot of opportunity for creators, film-makers who were earlier left out of the TV boom as that idiom of programming was considered regressive by most. So, I am hoping that one would see a deluge of quality original programming targeted at various demographics and geographies coming out of India in the near term. As for Arré, we are already working on over 140 hours of high-quality original shows (some for our own platform and a few in partnership with some of the domestic and international OTT players).

On Blockchain, I believe it’s a tad early, but it helps really disintermediate efficiently and this may be a boon for independent film makers and creators.

Then, I spoke to Suri Gopalanis, the Founder of Vista India Digital Media Inc., which distributes to the largest Indian studios and broadcasters with a focus on featuring films prominently on its partner platforms. Vista’s client list includes Red Chillies, Sun Network, Viacom18, Balaji Motion Pictures, Disney UTV, among others. Vista claims to be a pioneer in taking regional films on OTT platforms and having successfully delivered content in Indian languages like Marathi, Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, Bengali, Kannada, Punjabi, Oriya, Assamese and Gujarati across all our digital platforms. The company’s website can be found here.

[Suru Gopalanis of Vista India Digital Media Inc.]: With a remarkably young population and low cost of bandwidth, the Indian market has seen explosive growth in online video. While YouTube continues to dominate AVOD, we have a hyper-competitive OTT space (both domestic and International players) operating at all the different segments. As of now, we have over 32 platformswith financial muscle fighting for a pie of the Indian market which is expected to touch $ 5 billion by 2023. While primary consumption is still on mobile devices it is expected to gravitate towards TV with dongles and apps built into TV sets.

India is a price sensitive market. With average cable bundling at less than $2.00 per month, the ability for Indian consumers to pay in comparison to International markets still remains to be proven. Having said that, there are a number of price tiers at work domestically with a mixture of AD (AVOD) and SVOD to provide maximum economic value to consumers.

India is a very diverse country with many different regional languages and audiences. The segmentation of this online is relatively easier compared to standard broadcast TV. This, in turn, is leading to a number of niche regional platforms emerging in the pay markets that are targeted via language and tastes.

Sports continues to the biggest driver both offline and online with Cricket dominating minutes watched. There has been a lot of inflows into content development as audience tastes are changing and continue to beinfluenced by what’s happening in the West.

Indian audiences have been habituated to YouTube which has grown very aggressively in India and continues to attract advertising dollars. Given the diversity of content consumption, it is little wonder that DIY content in a host of niches has found audiences on YouTube.

With so much of competition, there is a need to create differentiated content and almost all the platforms including YouTube are investing in new original shows to attract and retain eyeballs.  We have seen a number of new shows which have been localized to multiple regional languages which is a new feature that OTT platforms have the advantage to experiment in.

In terms of independent features, there is not much good news. The consumption at this point appears to be to the big budget highly promoted features. Our hope is that a new generation of Indians will be more receptive to both foreign and Indian original films.

When at Film Bazaar I mentioned the launch of the Blockchain company to filmmakers and industry professionals the reaction was always extremely enthusiastic—It seems the right model for the market.…So I interviewed Nitin Narkhede, Founder & CEO of MinersINC, a new Blockchain platform/service that provides a unique opportunity to watch critically acclaimed films in India:

[Nitin Narkhede of MinersINC]: 2018 saw a progressive step forward for Indian independent cinema when Rima Das’ Village Rockstars became the country’s entry to the Oscars Best Foreign Language Film category.A passion project where Das and her school going cousins got together with a bunch of village kids to write, shoot, edit and direct this film entirely on hand held camera—Village Rockstars embodies the untapped, underutilized potential of self-trained, inspired and independent filmmakers in the country. That there is an audience for such cinema is evident to a logical mind, yet often left un-catered to by the country’s established filmmaking, distribution and exhibition segments. Das’ lilting, surreally beautiful film released in over 30 theatres in Assam and West Bengal and stayed on for over a month in very limited multiplex screens in Delhi and Bangalore, cities with sizeable and concentrated diaspora from the state. Village Rockstars had been screened at 88 film festivals, won 44 awards including four Swarna Kamals, the highest honors offered by the National Film Awards (India), to finally claim a restricted space in movie theatres.

This film elucidates aptly the absolute lack of a distribution mechanism for small, substantial and freethinking cinema or entertainment content within India. Another prime example is Mukti Bhawan, an introspective and moving film about death, old age and detachment. This film won critical acclaim in ten of the most respected film festivals, found theatrical releases in Japan and Germany, territories where familiarity with Hindi as a language is sparse.

Yet, in India, it barely found sufficient screen space- ultimately nesting on an OTT platform for viewers. Films that don’t boast of stars, celebrity filmmakers or the wizardry associated with mainstream movie making do not have a mechanism for their exhibition and distribution. Notwithstanding recognition globally, international independent films also never make it to an Indian audience’s viewing menu. With OTT platforms emerging in the country, some expected the restrictions that independent films, faced from a traditional, profit oriented distribution-exhibition system to change. Unfortunately, change for the small film, which rides on passion for a good, relevant story, is barely visible.

OTT platforms from international giants offer varied content but stay firmly focused on star-driven films and shows. English language content is also preferred by these platforms. Small, substantial films find room in a space where glitzier behemoths dominate.

Over the years, what we’ve come to firmly believe is that there is a definite audience keen on watching quality films, engaging stories from across the world here in India. With the country’s aspirational youth, levels of interest in cinema beyond typical Hollywood and Bollywood are evident. Given the challenges of access for such content, piracy often becomes a habit. Increasingly, world cinema that is shown at the film festivals, Cinefan by Osian and MAMI, based in Mumbai, runs to packed auditoriums. These films travel from across the globe, ranging from Iran, to South American nations, to East Asia and Europe. Watching them is top priority for the keen Indian cinephile today.

myNK, the OTT platform from MinersINC firmly focuses on filling this gap between demand and distribution of quality world cinema. Utilizing Blockchain technology, it ensures a safe, assured distribution platform for filmmakers to access a whole new audience that has only just begun consuming content on smart phonesand hand held devices. Currently, approximately 299 million people use smartphones in India. Over time, this number is expected to grow to 499 million as Reliance Jio expands access to high-speed data at very low prices. This is a market for movie consumption that simply has no match in terms of reach and numbers. The Hollywood Reporter has argued in a well-researched column that OTT giants like Netflix and Amazon PrimeVideo are battling it out to grow their share of the Indian video on demand market; simply because the numbers of video in India are mind boggling. In a scenario when mobile phones will often become access point for one’s personalized entertainment choices, myNK’s offering of critically acclaimed and quality world cinema offers a never before opportunity to access content for cinephiles.

Rapidly evolving digital technologies and declining costs of filmmaking equipment has led to a growth in the number of filmmakers worldwide. Rima Das, as explained, provides the perfect example. Finding an audience for these films though holds a real challenge. Additional problems that emerge are, firstly, a shortage of screens. India has just 10 screens per million people. When films don’t get released, they run the risks of getting pirated.Combined with high costs of acquiring distribution for a film often leave the film producer with no profits. Aside from this oligopolistic distribution model controlling content that makes it to a film theatre, marketing, sales and publicity for films are huge additional costs. Adding to the woes of the creator, there is a huge market of illegal downloads. Lopsides royalties and revenue distributions further reduce a creator’s earnings.

Conventional distribution mechanisms work in silos, somewhere incapacitating filmmakers and producers financially. Blockchain technology, as used by MinersINC, can help in resolving this opaque situation making a radical positive change by empowering creators in the long run. Blockchain technology naturally extends to the fundamental framework of how digital media gets distributed. It is a peer-to-peer decentralized network that brings the filmmakers in direct contact with their consumers without passing through the archaic distribution system. It gives leeway to filmmakers to bypass the costly distribution mediums and distribute their films directly to consumers. It has the potential to liberate the filmmakers by putting them back in control of their work and gives them complete autonomy on how their content gets distributed and priced. Parellely, consumers are empowered as they get the freedom to chose from a global library of films.

myNK, a product created by MinersINC envisages creating an entertainment ecosystem that will liberalize the industry from oligopolistic distribution practices, revenue dilution across middlemen, piracy, revenue leakages, copyright issues, breach of contracts, lost monetization, non-transparent earnings and unjust right attributions. Apart from addressing the current set of challenges, myNK aims at achieving greater goals by weaving the entities and components together in a fabric of trust and transparency, work on business models that make value sets more direct, less intricate and more rewarding.

In the long term, myNK aims to use blockchain technology to build an autonomous marketplace for creators to discover the real worth of their creations based on market governed dynamic pricing principals and community-driven curation. Consumers would have a significant role to play as they would act as a prudent community who will be collectively responsible for reviewing, rating, distributing, recommending and doing intelligent curation of content.

myNK empowers the creator and the consumer in Indian entertainment. Focused on bringing independent, recognized quality films from across the world, it will encourage interactions within the community, creating social media that has a definitive purpose. For those who love and live cinema, this platform is a valuable new opportunity to access worthy content while adding to a democratic, fair and collective voice for quality over hype in entertainment.

The Film Collaborative has had little or no success with its American or European indies in India but is now trying again with a curated selection to be distributed via MinersINC. Here’s hoping! And we will write again to update about changes in the India VOD market and with respect to Blockchain distribution.

Orly Ravid February 4th, 2019

Posted In: blockchain, Blockchain, Digital Distribution, Distribution, Documentaries, International Sales